danielcaux wrote:Holy fuck!! If this doesn't revive this forum then nothing will.
I think there are millions of "mainstream" fans who couldn't really care less about these. Its just us geeks that are interested. I cannot see a revolution coming, but I will do a story on the main website about it to generate some interest. Hopefully some people will comment on the forum here!
Haven't heard yet, will definitely listen today. Just wanted to say two things:
thank you
and
there definitely should be Animals Immerse box-set, I think they will just take their time after the current releases and release Animals Immerse a bit later, maybe in 2015. I do remember that most of such releases have been popping up only since a few years ago and that before that we used to complain about the lack of such.
Animals is my favorite album. Thanks for showing us this.
When I want to hear 'Dogs' (which is quite often), I now almost always listen to the Wembley performance (aka "You"ve Gotta Be Crazy") from the WYWH Immersion set (I think that's what it was on, anyway), so I would LOVE an Animals Immersion set.
I need to listen to these demos again before any critiquing though.
Sorry to disagree (somewhat) ladies & gents, but we DON'T need another fancy overpriced BOX. Instead, I'd like to see a double (or triple) hybrid multichannel SACD version of Animals with all the goodies on Disc 2 (and 3 if needed). The SQ would be stunning in proper surround. It's already great in 2.0! A vinyl (180g 2.0) release with all the extras would also be hugely popular, methinks. But I won't hold my breath for either ...
BTW, the WYWH Extraction set is up now too if you can find it (at Y, for example) ...........
Listening to them now and the Welcome to the Machine studio demo is really something special, a nice early version of the track. The talk box noodling is pretty awesome.
Also the full version of Shine On with all the different guitar and keyboard bits is awesome. It has a very nice feel to it, kinda like Echoes 2.0, taking up a whole side of the LP and just being a big long jam.
Well we already have official Dark Side demo tapes and a few demo versions of Obscured trackers were on a Harvested DVD as an easter egg, so Meddle or AHM being next would be pretty awesome.
jambo wrote:Well we already have official Dark Side demo tapes and a few demo versions of Obscured trackers were on a Harvested DVD as an easter egg, so Meddle or AHM being next would be pretty awesome.
jambo wrote:Well we already have official Dark Side demo tapes and a few demo versions of Obscured trackers were on a Harvested DVD as an easter egg, so Meddle or AHM being next would be pretty awesome.
jambo wrote:The WYWH Extraction Tapes are amazing.
Listening to them now and the Welcome to the Machine studio demo is really something special, a nice early version of the track. The talk box noodling is pretty awesome.
Yeah! I'm totally including that demo and some of the early synth-driven Waters demos of The Wall in a compilation for my own listening pleasure! The minimal production give all them this really dark and sinester and ominous Floyd sound. Too bad Roger didn't explore more of these textures with his solo records... instead of going all americana in Pros and Cons and 80s pop with KAOS
By the way who is the one talking in the middle of the song? Gilmour?
![[-D-]](./images/smilies/eusa_clap.gif "Applause"){kind=small}
