jambo wrote:I think that Sheep will be pretty bad, seeing as though Roger can't sing anymore .
Well, you were wrong about that. His vocals on Sheep were very good.
Oh, and the Gunner's Dream was excellent as always..and The Fletcher Memorial Home..outstanding version! He definitely can still sing! Brilliant guitar solo in Leaving Beirut, it sounds much better than the studio version.
jambo wrote:I think that Sheep will be pretty bad, seeing as though Roger can't sing anymore .
Well, you were wrong about that. His vocals on Sheep were very good.
Oh, and the Gunner's Dream was excellent as always..and The Fletcher Memorial Home..outstanding version! He definitely can still sing! Brilliant guitar solo in Leaving Beirut, it sounds much better than the studio version.
FloydCouncil wrote:I heard that Waters lip-synched, is this true? It was over there at the torrent on Dime a Dozen.
no. that?s a lie. maybe the persons that said that thought than when jonh carin was singing roger was doing playback.... some people next to me thought that....naiveness....
roger waters would never do playback and trash his reputation
FloydCouncil wrote:I heard that Waters lip-synched, is this true? It was over there at the torrent on Dime a Dozen.
no. that?s a lie. maybe the persons that said that thought than when jonh carin was singing roger was doing playback.... some people next to me thought that....naiveness....
roger waters would never do playback and trash his reputation
I'm not sure folks, he's sounding pretty good on this tour. Ok there were 2 occasions where Roger lyp-synched: One was for the ITF video on "Every strangers eyes" for one section of the song they had the original vocals playing. I'm assuming that at the concert Roger messed the vocal up and this bit was added on later. So at the actual concert they heard live Roger. I've heard bootlegs from this tour and Roger does not use the recording on them.
The only other occasion was on The Trial from "The Wall live in Berlin" but you must consider for both of these cases that it was done so that the official product would sound better. I would imagine that had either of these performances not been planned for an official release Roger wouldn't have lyp-synched.
In the pix on brain-damage.co.uk he has a Mr. Screen...sort of smaller one, a baby Mr. Screen And the screen extends past it to the sides, like the Australian PF stage. Anyone know if he has an airplane for On The Run or what kind of film he uses for it? That would kick ass to see the airplane fly across the audience at the Hollywood Bowl
On the LIVE8 DVD he re-recorded the vocals, and there are strong rumours from deep inside the rio concert, that Rog sang along to a tape of him singing the songs. So it was live+tape.