YAY! Someone on the forum agrees with me! I despise that song, only because of that hideous warbling. Musically, it's fine, and I like all the rest of Rick's songs.snifferdog wrote:I hope he performs something other than that godawful Great Gig in the Sky. I hate that that's what Rick's best remembered for.
I've always thought there was scope for a version of Great Gig with the vocals replaced with a similiar guitar part done by a certain Mr Gilmour ...my breakfast. wrote:Maybe as a fitting tribute we could get a special mix of Great Gig with Clair Tory taken off! I'm sure the piano is still doing crucial things under there.
It's not as special without Claire...Beowulf wrote:I've always thought there was scope for a version of Great Gig with the vocals replaced with a similiar guitar part done by a certain Mr Gilmour ...my breakfast. wrote:Maybe as a fitting tribute we could get a special mix of Great Gig with Clair Tory taken off! I'm sure the piano is still doing crucial things under there.
Don't get me wrong, I am not one of those who dislikes the original - far from it - I just thought there might be scope to do something a little different as an homage to Rickmoom wrote:It's not as special without Claire...Beowulf wrote:I've always thought there was scope for a version of Great Gig with the vocals replaced with a similiar guitar part done by a certain Mr Gilmour ...
Okay. Then, you can almost entirely remove vocals in Audacity - check out tutorials at YoutubeBeowulf wrote: Don't get me wrong, I am not one of those who dislikes the original - far from it - I just thought there might be scope to do something a little different as an homage to Rick
Sure, can you also get in touch with David and ask him nicely to replace them with a similar sounding guitar part?moom wrote:Okay. Then, you can almost entirely remove vocals in Audacity - check out tutorials at YoutubeBeowulf wrote: Don't get me wrong, I am not one of those who dislikes the original - far from it - I just thought there might be scope to do something a little different as an homage to Rick
Add your ownBeowulf wrote:Sure, can you also get in touch with David and ask him nicely to replace them with a similar sounding guitar part?moom wrote: Okay. Then, you can almost entirely remove vocals in Audacity - check out tutorials at Youtube
Syd'sSexy wrote:YAY! Someone on the forum agrees with me! I despise that song, only because of that hideous warbling.snifferdog wrote:I hope he performs something other than that godawful Great Gig in the Sky. I hate that that's what Rick's best remembered for.
It might be not the best of him, but surely one of the best, and despising that shocks. ![[-D-]](./images/smilies/eusa_clap.gif "Applause"){kind=small}
Yes, it was a good choice beautifully performedsnifferdog wrote:Great Gig in the Sky would have been a bit tasteless anyway. I'm glad David went for Remember A Day
Great choice, and yes, I HAVE TO agree on Great Gig... only Rick has the right to play it...Beowulf wrote:Yes, it was a good choice beautifully performedsnifferdog wrote:Great Gig in the Sky would have been a bit tasteless anyway. I'm glad David went for Remember A Day