The Big Pink Floyd Survey (January 2009) - Take Survey Now!

[Keith Jordan]

I changed Yugoslavia to Serbia. The list does not change alphabetical order automatically so is towards the bottom of the list after Yemen.

[Hudini]

Already voted as a South Sandwichian But thanks anyway.

[oldhippy]

Entered. Guess where I put Animals and the Final Cut. If they had a minus 10 I'd have gone for that.

[Keith Jordan]

Two of my favourites!

[Antonino]

Only queation now: when and where will we see
the results of this survey?


EDITED BY ADMIN - Image removed as it add nothing to the thread or post.

[jambo]

Done and done!

[wiped]

Done ...

[Keith Jordan]

776 surveys submitted now. Seems to be doing quite well.

I may have to get one of my old econometrics textbooks out to calculate the sample size needed to estimate with 95% confidence what the "population" answers would be in this survey. In English, how many people need to fill in the survey to allow me to say this % of "fans" in general think this.... with 95% confidence in saying it! I doubt it would be more than 1,000 or so. If anyone knows what I am talking about and the technique and formulas are fresh in their mind, do feel free to perform the calculations!

[PooF]

I am now a citizen of South Sandwich Islands, as far as this survey is concerned. I hope that's not a political issue.

Ha. I think I'll join you just to confuse the issue.

[henno]

done...

when will we first see results keith?? in the next newsletter?

[Keith Jordan]

I am now a citizen of South Sandwich Islands, as far as this survey is concerned. I hope that's not a political issue.

Ha. I think I'll join you just to confuse the issue.

I will delete your two responses.

There are 910 responses now. I think I will leave it a few days and see where it ends up then. I will do a feature for the NPF Magazine thing and let everyone know on here and in the newsletter too.

[Keith Jordan]

1000 results in now but I shall wait a week or so to see how many more come in before presenting and commenting upon the results.

Just to keep you talking (I hope) here are the current results for the ratings of the albums, summarised as weighted scores, i.e. not heard = # votes * 0, Excellent! = # votes * 5 etc.


01 - The Dark Side of the Moon - 4442
02 - Wish You Were Here - 4381
03 - The Wall - 4080
04 - Animals - 4034
05 - Meddle - 3764
06 - The Division Bell - 3427
07 - Piper At The Gates of Dawn - 3025
08 - Atom Heart Mother - 2982
09 - A Momentary Lapse of Reason - 2933
10 - The Final Cut - 2912
11 - A Saucerful of Secrets - 2844
12 - Obscured by Clouds - 2841
13 - Ummagumma - 2520
14 - Soundtrack from the Film More - 2183



Personally, I am absolutely disgusted where "A Momentary Lapse of Reason" currently is. Above the final cut???

[oz1701]

done!

[Keith Jordan]

Here are all the album weighted votes results now from 1023 completed surveys.

Pink Floyd

01 - The Dark Side of the Moon - 4946
02 - Wish You Were Here - 4887
03 - The Wall - 4547
04 - Animals - 4500
05 - Meddle - 4202
06 - The Division Bell - 3826
07 - Piper At The Gates of Dawn - 3362
08 - Atom Heart Mother - 3309
09 - A Momentary Lapse of Reason - 3279
10 - The Final Cut - 3273
11 - Obscured by Clouds - 3172
12 - A Saucerful of Secrets - 3163
13 - Ummagumma - 2787
14 - Soundtrack from the Film More - 2433

David Gilmour

01 - On An Island - 3382
02 - Live in Gdansk - 2951
03 - David Gilmour - 2530
04 - About Face - 2302

Roger Waters

01 - In the Flesh (Live) - 3066
02 - Amused to Death - 2969
03 - The Wall - Live in Berlin - 2779
04 - The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking - 2601
05 - Radio K.A.O.S. - 2328
06 - Music from The Body - 1214
07 - Ça Ira - 1026

Syd, Nick, and Rick

01 - Syd Barrett - The Madcap Laughs - 2250
02 - Syd Barrett - Barrett - 2075
03 - Richard Wright - Broken China - 1795
04 - Richard Wright - Wet Dream - 1589
05 - Nick Mason's Fictitious Sports - 865
06 - Zee feat. Richard Wright - Identity - 791

[zzottt]

I cant wait to see the results.

BTW thanks alot for the NPF Newsletter
its always a welcome email