The Big Pink Floyd Survey (January 2009) - Take Survey Now!

[Keith Jordan]

Glad you like the newsletter. Its a bit of fun and can be informative too!

Welcome to the forum also, zzottt!

I am looking forward to the complete results too. I have had a quick look at things as they stand but not looked into the details in depth just yet.

The surveys are still coming in strong. 1154 of them now.

Do spread the word about the survey on other forums people! The more poeple who respond, the better.

[PooF]

I will delete your two responses.

Don't worry Hudini, there are millions of S Georgia & S Sandwich PF fans. He will never know which 2 we are are!

[Keith Jordan]

I have put a lot of hard work into this survey. Why are you trying to mess it up?

[Harpo]

I was very impressed with the included songs - Give Birth To A Smile, Vegetable Man, etc

any chance we can see which songs have had zero votes so far?

[Keith Jordan]

My data download only has songs that have been voted for in it so not just at the minute. I could do it but would take 15 mins that I dont have!! You could deduce it I guess.

Here are the songs that all have at least one vote on them. Some surprising ones!! Most votes for ones at the top, least at the bottom.

Echoes
Comfortably Numb
Shine On You Crazy Diamond Parts I-V
Wish You Were Here
Dogs
Time
Us and Them
Careful With That Axe Eugene
High Hopes
Atom Heart Mother
The Great Gig in the Sky
Brain Damage
Breathe
Astronomy Domine
Pigs Three Different Ones
Cymbaline
Shine On You Crazy Diamond Parts VI-IX
Eclipse
Fat Old Sun
On The Turning Away
One of These Days
Sheep
Welcome to the Machine
Coming Back To Life
Hey You
Mother
See Emily Play
The Final Cut
The Gunner's Dream
A Saucerful of Secrets
Cirrus Minor
Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun
When the Tigers Broke Free
Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast
Any Colour You Like
Fearless
Have A Cigar
Interstellar Overdrive
Learning To Fly
Lucifer Sam
Run Like Hell
Sorrow
A Pillow of Winds
Another Brick in the Wall Part II
Bike
Childhood's End
Flaming
Green Is The Colour
Jugband Blues
Lost For Words
Marooned
Money
Wot's... Uh the Deal?
Biding My Time
Julia Dream
Other
Summer '68
Yet Another Movie
Absolutely Curtains
Arnold Layne
Come in Number 51 Your Time Is Up
Don't Leave Me Now
Embryo
Empty Spaces
Free Four
Goodbye Blue Sky
If
In The Flesh?
Is There Anybody Out There?
Keep Talking
Let There Be More Light
Nobody Home
Not Now John
On the Run
Paranoid Eyes
Pow R. Toc H.
Remember A Day
Several Species Of Small Furry
Take It Back
Terminal Frost
The Fletcher Memorial Home
The Nile Song
The Scarecrow
The Trial
Two Suns in the Sunset
Vegetable Man
Wearing the Inside Out
What Do You Want from Me

[oz1701]

I have put a lot of hard work into this survey.

i could see that.

[PooF]

I have put a lot of hard work into this survey. Why are you trying to mess it up?

Yes, you have. Sorry.

It won't make much difference though. I mean, if there are more than 2 of us I'll eat a penguin or something.

[Keith Jordan]

The survey is going great. 1,600 responses now which is nice.

I have posted a few threads around on some other Floyd sites to get other people involved too. I shall make the results available in a nice PDF file so people can stick it on their own websites if they like!

I posted details of the survey on that horrible PFCO website and they decided to delete my thread! How pathetic and rude!! The agreeable and nice people at Col Turner's site and Pink Floyd Online are more positive about it!

If anyone participates in any other Floyd sites, then please do spread the word and ask your friends there to participate.

[oz1701]

when do you publish some results Keith - should be interesting - kinda like a blind taste test.

[Keith Jordan]

I am going to see how long it takes to get to 2,000 surveys submitted as that would be more reflective of fans in general I think. Or tomorrow.

[oz1701]

fair enough.

[Real Pink in the Inside]

I posted details of the survey on that horrible PFCO website and they decided to delete my thread! How pathetic and rude!!

We're supposed to believe that PFCO stands for "Pink Floyd & Company"? HA! HA! Pink Fraud & Con Artists is more like it.

PFCO is not even a real fan's Pink Floyd website, so I would not worry about it. Unfortunately, there are always going to be some people who are jealous of the good ideas found on this site (e.g., the big survey, NPF Webzine, numerous threads on this board, etc.)

[Keith Jordan]

Based on 1536 responses, here are the favourite allbums so far. Once again, they have a weighted score based on how people rated them.

Pink Floyd

01 - The Dark Side of the Moon - 7265
02 - Wish You Were Here - 7180
03 - The Wall - 6685
04 - Animals - 6620
05 - Meddle - 6169
06 - The Division Bell - 5576
07 - Piper At The Gates of Dawn - 4918
08 - Atom Heart Mother - 4851
09 - The Final Cut - 4838
10 - A Momentary Lapse of Reason - 4822
11 - Obscured by Clouds - 4686
12 - A Saucerful of Secrets - 4656
13 - Ummagumma - 4145
14 - Soundtrack from the Film More - 3651

David Gilmour

01 - On An Island - 4905
02 - Live in Gdansk - 4313
03 - David Gilmour - 3731
04 - About Face - 3394

Roger Waters

01 - In the Flesh (Live) - 4477
02 - Amused to Death - 4428
03 - The Wall - Live in Berlin - 4024
04 - The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking - 3835
05 - Radio K.A.O.S. - 3463
06 - Music from The Body - 1799
07 - Ça Ira - 1498

Syd, Nick, and Rick

01 - Syd Barrett - The Madcap Laughs - 3313
02 - Syd Barrett - Barrett - 3062
03 - Richard Wright - Broken China - 2589
04 - Richard Wright - Wet Dream - 2321
05 - Nick Mason's Fictitious Sports - 1242
06 - Zee feat. Richard Wright - Identity - 1135

[Hogtown]

Nice shoes.

[David Smith]

Surprised to see The Division Bell doing better than Piper

Even more surprised to see someone voted on Terminal Frost