Who Was Pink Floyd's Chief Songwriter?

[mosespa]

*laughs out loud for ten seconds while rubbing eyes and bemoaning the absence of a smilie to cover this level of hilarity*

That was BRILLIANT, man. Well played and all that.

[Idisaffect]

I thought for sure someone would confuse Seamus with Mademoiselle Nobbs and tell me it was a female dog.

[snifferdog]

Well, with a name like Mademoiselle (K)nobs, there has to be some confusion.

[PublicImage]

Sorry, Bong, but some entries on your list are inaccurate. For example, Let There Be More Light was written by Waters, not Gilmour.

And what's that IN you used in the list (like "Ummagumma (studio side only) 1-In") ?

Did you just take bong seriously? 5/5.

[moom]

Sorry, Bong, but some entries on your list are inaccurate. For example, Let There Be More Light was written by Waters, not Gilmour.

And what's that IN you used in the list (like "Ummagumma (studio side only) 1-In") ?

Did you just take bong seriously? 5/5.

He's probably my bro Wonder why he had never showed up while I was here.

[Real Pink in the Inside]

He's probably my bro Wonder why he had never showed up while I was here.

No, HeckTo is probably your bro. Yes, that is a compliment

[moom]

He's probably my bro Wonder why he had never showed up while I was here.

No, HeckTo is probably your bro. Yes, that is a compliment

Jedi was my bro as well, until he got too mad at The Force

[bong2]

I'd be more than happy to see what the results are for lead singing on a minute by minute basis, or second by second.

[Real Pink in the Inside]

I'd be more than happy to see what the results are for lead singing on a minute by minute basis, or second by second.

Your are more than welcome to undertake that task yourself. This is not the R.PITI of PinkFloyd.com/PinkFan.com

[mosespa]

This IS, however, the mosespa of pinkfloyd.com/pinkfan...and I hereby state as fact that those listings would NOT change on a minute by minute nor second by second basis.

[Real Pink in the Inside]

This IS, however, the mosespa of pinkfloyd.com/pinkfan...and I hereby state as fact that those listings would NOT change on a minute by minute nor second by second basis.

God, you must hate knowing everything, yes?

[mosespa]

I hate knowing everything...but maybe it's just me...........

[Annoying Twit]

You will not believe what I stumbled upon on an old hard drive: A categorized list of the songwriting credits for the vast majority of Pink Floyd's catalog from SoS through The Final Cut. By popular request, I present yet another list that objectively answers an oft-debated question:

You've missed out three PF albums. Particularly the two albums after Roger left. This is a classic case of "how to lie with statistics".

Nobody would deny that Rog wrote more PF songs than any other single member. But this attempt to exaggerate that is just silly.

[David Smith]

Not really lying with statistics. What he's showing is that in the entire time that both Dave and Roger were in the band Roger wrote considerably more songs. The only thing that can be considered underhanded is that The Wall adds 26 of them

[mosespa]

Yeah...but even considering AMLOR and TDB, Roger STILL wrote more songs than Gilmour.