Finally!

[Ridan]

Alright everybody. Taking into consideration the votes from my last thread named Should We! I am going to post the list of the songs that will be incluced. For those not in the know, refer to the following link:

http://www.neptunepinkfloyd.co.uk/for/v ... php?t=2741

They include songs on the officially released albums and other few singles, if that's the right word.

Take a look at this long long list and let me know if there is any song that you might think is missing. They are in alphabetical order for your convenience. RoIOs do NOT count If you find any of those in this list, let me know. I tend to be careless

Additions, objections and suggestions are invited.

This done, we'll then progress to the next stage.

And on a second note, you might want to display some enthusiasm

Here's the list. I think they are 172 in total

---

A great day for freedom
A new machine (part 1)
A new machine (part 2)
A pillow of winds
A Saucerful Of Secrets
A Spanish Piece
Absolutely Curtains
Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast
Another brick in the wall (part 1)
Another brick in the wall (part 2)
Another brick in the wall (part 3)
Any Colour You Like
Apples & Oranges
Arnold Layne
Astronomy domine
Atom Heart Mother
Baby Lemonade
Biding my time
Bike
Brain damage
Breathe
Breathe reprise
Bring the boys back home
Burning bridges
Candy And A Currant Bun
Careful With That Axe, Eugene
Chapter 24
Childhood's end
Cirrus Minor
Clowns and Jugglers
Cluster One
Come in Number 51, Your Time is Up
Comfortably numb
Coming back to life
Corporal Clegg
Country Song
Crumbling land
Crying Song
Cymbaline
Dogs
Don't leave me now
Dramatic Theme
Echoes
Eclipse
Embryo
Empty spaces
Fat old sun
Fearless
Flaming
Free four
Get your filthy hands off my desert
Gigolo Aunt
Golden Hair
Goodbye blue sky
Goodbye cruel world
Grantchester meadows
Green is the colour
Have a cigar
Heart Beat, Pig Meat
Hey you
High Hopes
Ibiza Bar
If
In the Flesh
In the Flesh (II)
Interstellar Overdrive
Is there anybody out there?
It would be so nice
Jugband blues
Julia dream
Keep Talking
Lanky (Part One)
Late Night
Learning to fly
Let's Roll Another One
Let there be more light
Lost for words
Lucifer Sam
Main Theme
Marooned
Matilda Mother
Money
More Blues
Mother
Mudmen
No Good Trying
Nobody home
Not now John
Obscured by Clouds
Octopus
On The Run
On the turning away
One of my turns
One of the few
One of these days
One slip
Opel
Outside the wall
Paint box
Paranoid eyes
Party Sequence
Pigs on the wing (part 1)
Pigs on the wing (part 2)
Pigs (3 different ones )
Point me at the sky
Poles Apart
Pow R. Toc H.
Quicksilver
Remember a day
Round and Round
Run Like Hell
San Tropez
Seamus
See Emily play
See saw
Set the controls for the heart of the sun
Several Species of Small Furry Animals ...
Sheep
Shine on you crazy diamond (part I-V)
Shine on you crazy diamond (part VI-IX)
Signs of Life
Sorrow
Southampton dock
Speak to Me
Stay
Stop
Summer '68
Swan Lee (Silas Lang)
Sysyphus
Take it back
Take up the Stethoscope and walk
Terminal Frost
The dogs of war
The final cut
The fletcher memorial home
The Gnome
The gold it's in the....
The Grand Vizier's Garden Party: Part One (Entrance)
The Grand Vizier's Garden Party: Part Three (Exit)
The Grand Vizier's Garden Party: Part Two (Entertainment)
The Great Gig in the Sky
The gunners dream
The happiest days of our lives
The hero's return
The narrow way
The nile song
The post war dream
The Scarecrow
The show must go on
The thin ice
The trial
Time
Two suns in the sunset
Up the Khyber
Us and them
Vera
Waiting for the worms
Waving My Arms In The Air/Never Lied To You (continuous)
Wearing the inside out
Welcome to the machine
What do you want from me
What shall we do now
When the Tigers broke free
When You're In
Wined And Dined
Wish you were here
Wolfpack
Wot's...uh deal
Yet another movie
Young lust
Your possible pasts

[kipnow]

Opel isn't from Pink Floyd, is it?

[ganaffe]

On first note, these songs are all solo work from Syd, I think:
Baby Lemonade
Clowns and Jugglers
Gigolo Aunt
Golden Hair
Lanky (Part One)
Late Night
No Good Trying
Octopus
Opel
Swan Lee (Silas Lang)
Waving My Arms In The Air/Never Lied To You (continuous)
Wined And Dined
Wolfpack

And I think 'Let's Roll Another One' is the same as 'candy and currant bun' with a few different lyrics...

On second note: I show my enthousiasm impressive list!

[Ridan]

Well thank you Ganaffe. Enthusiasm much appreciated

They'll be removed from the list.

Anything isn't missing is it?

For others: the list doesn't scare ya does it?

[ganaffe]

Anything isn't missing is it?

No, I don't think so...
I just realized you included some tracks form the Zabriskie Point soundtrack:

Crumbling land
Country song
Heart beat, pig meat
Come number 51, your time is up

The last of those (come in number 51) is an alternate version of Careful with that axe, Eugene... although radically different, especially the second half...
I will leave the decision up to you, since this is your project
About the other songs from Zabriski Point I'm not sure... but I think they are 'unique' tracks.

How about the next step? Do you plan on creating some database in which everyone can enter his own top XX? Or should we just post them here, or mail them to you? Entering al those numbers by yourself will be a pain, I think...

[seamusz]

Can we put the songs Astronomy Domine, Careful With That Axe Eugene, Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun, and Saucerful Of Secrets from the Ummagumma Live cd? Maybe its just redundant.

[Powderfinger]

Can we put the songs Astronomy Domine, Careful With That Axe Eugene, Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun, and Saucerful Of Secrets from the Ummagumma Live cd? Maybe its just redundant.

I would not do that. Idf you start with putting a few life-songs on the list, you have to put all the live songs on the list, and then there are teice as much songs to choose from.

[Jack Dempsey]

There will be a lot of heads banging about this one.
Looks interesting.

[simpledumbpilot]

It is a toughy regaurding the live versions, the Celestial Voices part of Saucerful is very different live and is one of my fave Floyd moments so if I were to include Saucerful in my picks it would be because of the live version but as had been said there are so many alternatives live the list would be never ending but maybe the Ummagumma tracks should be included as they are officially released but of course that then opens up DSoT, PULSE and ITAOT which would nearly double the size of the list so its hard to say, I guess it would depend on how the poll is compiled, if its just a simple case of voting in the same way we do on the polls here but restricted to say 10 votes per person then it would be quite simple but if poor old Ridan has to count up all these then its probably easier to leave them off.

[seamusz]

I think that the four live tracks on Ummagumma are different than the later live sets. But, after thinking about it, it wouldnt be all that fun if there were two of the same song on the final list. Its probably fine without differentiating on the list, but when the song is disscussed, there could be conversation about which version is best... just a thought.

[ganaffe]

I think that the four live tracks on Ummagumma are different than the later live sets. But, after thinking about it, it wouldnt be all that fun if there were two of the same song on the final list. Its probably fine without differentiating on the list, but when the song is disscussed, there could be conversation about which version is best... just a thought.

I think that's a nice idea... maybe we could just take the songtitle and stick to the concept of the song, not so much a particular version. In discussing them we can point out which versions are good/bad etc.
When voting just think of the nicest version of the song you know. When you like the live version of SOS un Ummagumma very much you can just vote for SOS...

By the time we are going to publish the results of this project in the New York Times we can always add some comments about particular good live versions etc.

[Flame-Sky Diver]

I agree ...and I'm showing my enthusiasm

[Eugene]

In my opinion you could insert in your list "MOONHEAD"
It wasn't never released but it's a PF song and it isn't from a RoIO.
But... the last word is your.

Ciao and be careful with that...
Eugene

[nosaj]

Perhaps live official releases should not be in this - they are to be taken as whole concerts - even Ummagumma. These could be for a later live list. I like the idea of singles (I would love rare unreleased stuff too, but maybe another list) in the context of official releases. What about Love Scene etc. from Zambriski Point?

[Ridan]

The last of those (come in number 51) is an alternate version of Careful with that axe, Eugene... although radically different, especially the second half...
I will leave the decision up to you, since this is your project
About the other songs from Zabriski Point I'm not sure... but I think they are 'unique' tracks.

You think the song you mentioned should be included? And the other Zabriskie Point songs? If yes then either we include all of them or remove all of them. What do you think?

How about the next step? Do you plan on creating some database in which everyone can enter his own top XX? Or should we just post them here, or mail them to you? Entering al those numbers by yourself will be a pain, I think...

What I have in mind for the moment in people will send me their all time top 10 or 15 at via e-mail. Then I'll sort them out. How? Check your PM Ganaffe

Yes people you'll have to some thinking.

Can we put the songs Astronomy Domine, Careful With That Axe Eugene, Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun, and Saucerful Of Secrets from the Ummagumma Live cd? Maybe its just redundant.

I would not do that. Idf you start with putting a few life-songs on the list, you have to put all the live songs on the list, and then there are teice as much songs to choose from.

Yeah I agree. I plan to do one with live songs after this one. I'm bored aren't I?

It is a toughy regaurding the live versions, the Celestial Voices part of Saucerful is very different live and is one of my fave Floyd moments so if I were to include Saucerful in my picks it would be because of the live version but as had been said there are so many alternatives live the list would be never ending but maybe the Ummagumma tracks should be included as they are officially released but of course that then opens up DSoT, PULSE and ITAOT

That's right. The list would be long and that enough should make my hair go white I think I'm cool with them being black for the moment

then it would be quite simple but if poor old Ridan has to count up all these then its probably easier to leave them off.

Thanks for the concern SDP Soon enough we'll out the prefered way of going about it. After opinions from you all

By the time we are going to publish the results of this project in the New York Times we can always add some comments about particular good live versions etc.

I was thinking of TIME magazine Wouldn't it be cool to have our own list It would be a slap on Rolling Stones and other magazines' face for their stupid lame polls

In my opinion you could insert in your list "MOONHEAD"
It wasn't never released but it's a PF song and it isn't from a RoIO.
But... the last word is your.

Somebody tell me more about Moonhead.