Finally!

[madcap69]

What nothing from Lacarrera panAmerica

[Fox-Mike]

Just assume that each song includes all live versions played. I mean, there are A LOT of alternate studio tracks as well, so if you include pulse, ummagumma, etc. etc., you'd most likely have to include the alternate zabreskie point sessions also, and probably more. It's just easier to say "this song represents all other versions of the song."

[Powderfinger]

What I have in mind for the moment in people will send me their all time top 10 or 15 at via e-mail. Then I'll sort them out.

It might be usefull to tell your e-mailadress then, because I didn't now it, I send my top 10 via the Private Mail-option.

I plan to do one with live songs after this one.

[ganaffe]

Hey Ridan & everybody else

I think I answered most of your questions by PM.
One other thing: maybe it would be OK to post a message here with the rules of the game... (where to post your toplist, how many songs it should contain etc.). Since you're the moderator here I think that's a nice task for you
Since I'm your humble serf I will help you with counting the votes.

[Ridan]

Here's the final list. I've included the tracks from Zabriskie Point. Taken out the ones Ganaffe told me were from Syd. Moonhead is not included.

A great day for freedom
A new machine (part 1)
A new machine (part 2)
A pillow of winds
A Saucerful Of Secrets
A Spanish Piece
Absolutely Curtains
Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast
Another brick in the wall (part 1)
Another brick in the wall (part 2)
Another brick in the wall (part 3)
Any Colour You Like
Apples & Oranges
Arnold Layne
Astronomy domine
Atom Heart Mother
Biding my time
Bike
Brain damage
Breathe
Breathe reprise
Bring the boys back home
Burning bridges
Candy And A Currant Bun
Careful With That Axe, Eugene
Chapter 24
Childhood's end
Cirrus Minor
Cluster One
Come in Number 51, Your Time is Up
Comfortably numb
Coming back to life
Corporal Clegg
Country Song
Crumbling land
Crying Song
Cymbaline
Dogs
Don't leave me now
Dramatic Theme
Echoes
Eclipse
Embryo
Empty spaces
Fat old sun
Fearless
Flaming
Free four
Get your filthy hands off my desert
Goodbye blue sky
Goodbye cruel world
Grantchester meadows
Green is the colour
Have a cigar
Heart Beat, Pig Meat
Hey you
High Hopes
Ibiza Bar
If
In the Flesh
In the Flesh (II)
Interstellar Overdrive
Is there anybody out there?
It would be so nice
Jugband blues
Julia dream
Keep Talking
Learning to fly
Let's roll another one
Let there be more light
Lost for words
Love Scene-Version 4
Love Scene-Version 6
Lucifer Sam
Main Theme
Marooned
Matilda Mother
Money
More Blues
Mother
Mudmen
Nobody home
Not now John
Obscured by Clouds
On The Run
On the turning away
One of my turns
One of the few
One of these days
One slip
Outside the wall
Paint box
Paranoid eyes
Party Sequence
Pigs on the wing (part 1)
Pigs on the wing (part 2)
Pigs (3 different ones )
Point me at the sky
Poles Apart
Pow R. Toc H.
Quicksilver
Remember a day
Round and Round
Run Like Hell
San Tropez
Seamus
See Emily play
See saw
Set the controls for the heart of the sun
Several Species of Small Furry Animals ...
Sheep
Shine on you crazy diamond (part I-V)
Shine on you crazy diamond (part VI-IX)
Signs of Life
Sorrow
Southampton dock
Speak to Me
Stay
Stop
Summer '68
Sysyphus
Take it back
Take up the Stethoscope and walk
Terminal Frost
The dogs of war
The final cut
The fletcher memorial home
The Gnome
The gold it's in the....
The Grand Vizier's Garden Party: Part One (Entrance)
The Grand Vizier's Garden Party: Part Three (Exit)
The Grand Vizier's Garden Party: Part Two (Entertainment)
The Great Gig in the Sky
The gunners dream
The happiest days of our lives
The hero's return
The narrow way
The nile song
The post war dream
The Scarecrow
The show must go on
The thin ice
The trial
Time
Two suns in the sunset
Unknown Song
Up the Khyber
Us and them
Vera
Waiting for the worms
Wearing the inside out
Welcome to the machine
What do you want from me
What shall we do now
When the Tigers broke free
When You're In
Wish you were here
Wot's...uh deal
Yet another movie
Young lust
Your possible pasts

---------

Just assume that each song includes all live versions played. I mean, there are A LOT of alternate studio tracks as well, so if you include pulse, ummagumma, etc. etc., you'd most likely have to include the alternate zabreskie point sessions also, and probably more. It's just easier to say "this song represents all other versions of the song."

I think that would make it very confusing. Therefore, here's the good news. After this one is done, and I hope it's a success, I'll start one on the live versions of Pink Floyd

At the moment let's concentrate at the list I posted. It's been checked and re-checked. I'm sure you won't be disappointed if you stick to it

because I didn't now it, I send my top 10 via the Private Mail-option.

Thanks Syd I got your PM. Please check yours

I plan to do one with live songs after this one.

*Bows down to the applause*

You can start sending me your top ten at this e-mail address - [email protected] That's ridaneightyone at yahoo dot com

Please make sure they are in descending order.

After 7 days no votes will be accepted.

Please inform other members of the board who may not know what's going on

[Eclipse]

um...can i put the old CWTA, Eugene version ''Murderistic Women'' in that list???

[Ridan]

Is that an official release?

[jebcdex]

Were "Scream Thy Last Scream" and "Vegetable Man" officially released?
If so, to the list with them.

Hope it hasn't been mentioned already.

[Meddler]

I think if the song is original and not a live diverivitive then it should be added. But no known solo songs released or not.

[simpledumbpilot]

Heros Return Part 2 from the Not Now John single isnt on the list, as far as I can tell thats the only officially released track record wise not on the list. Its hard to know exactly how extensive the list should be, another thing to consider is the La Carrera Panamericana tracks are also officially released, albeit on video, which of course also brings up the track commonly known as Pompeii at the beginning of the Live at Pompeii release. Technically these tracks are officially released, and of course there is a european release of the More film on video which also means that in its way Seabirds has been officially released, aaargh its never ending!!!! Mind you I dont think anyone would vote for these tracks anyway.

@jebcdex: no they havent unfortunately, at least not yet anyway.

[Powderfinger]

Were "Scream Thy Last Scream" and "Vegetable Man" officially released?
If so, to the list with them.

Hope it hasn't been mentioned already.

Those were Syb Barrett solo songs.

[decampos]

Were "Scream Thy Last Scream" and "Vegetable Man" officially released?
If so, to the list with them.

Hope it hasn't been mentioned already.

Those were Syb Barrett solo songs.

no they weren't.

[Powderfinger]

Those were Syd Barrett solo songs.

no they weren't.

Have they been released on an album?

[ganaffe]

no they weren't.

Have they been released on an album?

When it comes to official releases: they were only released as solo tracks by Syd. There are some of those 'outtakes' RoIO's which contain studio versions of the songs by Pink Floyd. And on very early live RoIO's (from 1967, I think) the songs are played live by Pink Floyd.

As far as I know there are no official studio releases of the songs under the name Pink Floyd.

[simpledumbpilot]

When it comes to official releases: they were only released as solo tracks by Syd.

Sorry but there are no official releases of them by Syd solo, I dont think there are any solo recordings of these by Syd. Theres the Top Gear versions and the studio recordings in various states, some with the Laughing Gnome style overdub, some without, each have surfaced in either stereo or mono.