Echoes... Which CD Do You Perfer?

[Meddler]

Which CD is better off of Echoes? This is a hard one I know... but give it a shot:

Disc I

1. Astronomy Domine
From 'Piper at the Gates of Dawn'

2. See Emily Play
Early 1967 Single featuring 'Scarecrow'

3. The Happiest Days Of Our Lives
From 'The Wall'

4. Another Brick In The Wall (Part 2)
From 'The Wall'

5. Echoes
Edited down from 'Meddle'

6. Hey You
From 'The Wall'

7. Marooned
From 'Division Bell'

8. The Great Gig In The Sky
From 'Dark Side of the Moon'

9. Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun
From 'A Saucerful of Secrets'

10. Money
From 'Dark Side of the Moon'

11. Keep Talking
From 'The Division Bell'

12. Sheep
From 'Animals'

13. Sorrow
From 'Momentary Lapse of Reason'

Disc II

1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts 1-7)
From 'Wish You Were Here'

2. Time
From 'Dark Side of the Moon'

3. The Fletcher Memorial Home
From 'The Final Cut'

4. Comfortably Numb
From 'The Wall'

5. When The Tigers Broke Free
From the movie 'The Wall Movie'

6. One Of These Days
From 'Meddle'

7. Us And Them
From 'Dark Side of the Moon'

8. Learning To Fly
From 'Momentary Lapse of Reason'

9. Arnold Layne
Early 1967 Single featuring "Candy and A Currant Bun"

10. Wish You Were Here
From 'Wish You Were Here'

11. Jugband Blues
From 'A Saucerful of Secrets'

12. High Hopes
From "The Division Bell"

13. Bike
From 'Piper at the Gates of Dawn'

[eternalechoes]

While both discs contain great tracks, disc 2 has more of Pink Floyd's better known hits.

[Feeling Very Pink]

Er, disc two, I guess. Greater emotional resonance.

[David Smith]

Disc 2, although there's not a lot in it. Disc 1 has more good songs but disc 2 has better good songs.

[Tommy]

neither, dont like the compilation too much

[Spirit Catcher]

Disc 2 for me .. WOW the first 6 votes are the same

[Meddler]

yeah, I went with disc 2 as well... obviously... lol

[dogs_pigs_n_sheep]

neither, dont like the compilation too much

The whole idea of mixed up PF songs feels anti-PF, doesn't it?

[David Smith]

I agree with Tommy a bit actually, it really isn't a particularly good best off.

Still, it would be impossible to make a perfect Pink Floyd best off anyway so i suppose it's a fir enough attempt.