Fantasy Setlist

[fatoldbob]

Ok, fantasy setlist for upcoming tour. Doesn't have to based on what he's actually playing ( like the entire Dark Side. )

Here's mine:

Entire WYWH album
Interstellar Overdrive

Set 2
In the Flesh
Young Lust
Saucer
Mother
Gunners Dream
Green is the Colour
If
Dogs

Encore
Echoes

[PublicImage]

Interstellar Overdrive and ASOS seem like odd choices, being tracks done by all the members of Pink Floyd. I can't imagine tour musicians playing them.

[fatoldbob]

You could say the same about Breathe, Time and Us and Them, but he's playing them currently.

[Groovybass77]

Here is what i think he will play on his 2007 tour:

Set One

1. In the Flesh
2. Mother
3. Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun
4. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I - V)
5. Have a Cigar
6. Wish You Were Here
7. Southampton Dock
8. The Fletcher Memorial Home
9. Perfect Sense, Parts 1 and 2
10. Leaving Beirut
11. Sheep


Set Two (The Dark Side of the Moon)

1. Speak to Me
2. Breathe
3. On the Run
4. Time
5. Breathe (Reprise)
6. The Great Gig in the Sky
7. Money
8. Us and Them
9. Any Colour You Like
10. Brain Damage
11. Eclipse

Encore

1. The Happiest Days of Our Lives
2. Another Brick in the Wall, Part II
3. Vera
4. Bring the Boys Back Home
5. Comfortably Numb

[darkfrost12]

When the Tigers Broke Free
In the Flesh
Shine On
WYWH (84 or 87 version)
Post War Dream
Southampton Dock
Fletcher Memorial Home
Gunners Dream
Pros and Cons part 10
Every Strangers Eyes
The Final Cut
Sheep

What God Wants 1
Perfect Sense
Bravery of Being Out of Range
Late Home Tonight
Towers of Faith
What God Wants 2 & 3
Three Wishes
Amused to Death

Encores:
Hey You
Nobody Home
ABITW/happiest days/ABITW 2
Folded Flags
Dogs

[PublicImage]

You could say the same about Breathe, Time and Us and Them, but he's playing them currently.

Yes, you could. But it is different and that comparison is illogical.

ASOS and Interstellar Overdrive are highly improvisational and only follow any pre-arranged chord structure at the end (in the case of both) and the start (just Interstellar Overdrive), while all of the songs you mentioned are not very improvisational at all and each one has a composed harmonic structure. Performing them is completely different to performing ASOS and Interstellar Overdrive.

[fatoldbob]

Yes, you could. But it is different and that comparison is illogical.

ASOS and Interstellar Overdrive are highly improvisational and only follow any pre-arranged chord structure at the end (in the case of both) and the start (just Interstellar Overdrive), while all of the songs you mentioned are not very improvisational at all and each one has a composed harmonic structure. Performing them is completely different to performing ASOS and Interstellar Overdrive.

The comparison is perfectly logical as your previous assertion is that the songs required all the members of Floyd, not that they were too improvisational.

The improvisational nature of those songs is why I choose them. One of my major complaints about the show this fall is how the musicians needed to loosen up. As Clapton once said while touring with Roger: "Can't we just play?"

I'm sure Jon Carin can improvise on the spot and I would be surprised if Mr. Kilminster couldn't find a few licks in a pinch. Not all musicians need a defined chord structure to improvise a melodic line, jazz players have been doing it for the last 40 years. I actually think I would enjoy Kilminster's playing more if it didn't sound like a thin, lick for lick copy of Gilmour.

[Sonic Destruction]

Fantasy Setlist:

Set One
1) Astronomy Dominee
2) Set The Controls
3) Welcome To The Machine
4) The Pros And Cons Of Hitchhiking (part X)
5) Sexual Revolution
6) Every Strangers Eyes
7) One Of These Days
8) Three Wishes
9) It's A Miracle
10) When The Tigers Broke Free (acoustic)
11) Granchester Meadows (acoustic)
12) Nobody Home (acoustic)
13) Another Brick In The Wall (medley parts I-III)

Set Two
1) Complete Animals

Encore
1) Wish You Were Here
2) Breathe (inc Breathe reprise)
3) Brain Damage
4) Eclipse

[Tenniru]

I had a topic like this once. In fact, it features my most oft-copy-pasted piece of text, which you will now see.

SET 1

1. Radio Waves
2. Happiest Days Of Our Lives (KAOS arrangement with piano solo)
3. ABITW II (KAOS arrangement with no instruments in first few words)
4. Get Your Filthy Hands Off My Desert/Southampton Docks (Rog ALONE)
5. Sunset Strip
6. In The Flesh? (Fast)
7. Pigs (Two Diffirent Ones, remove Whitehouse and solos; segue from ITF)
8. Wish You Were Here (KAOS arrangement, plus segue from Pigs)
9. Every Stranger's Eyes (sing screamed bit in strangled present voice)
10. What God Wants (pt. 1)
11. Towers Of Faith (speak the Pope's line, not scream)
12. Set The Controls (Present arrangement)
13. Shine On You Crazy Diamond
14. Calls To The Hall (you heard me)

SET 2
1. Speak To Me/Breathe
2. Perfect Sense (pt. 1)
3. The Pros And Cons Of Hitchhiking (with 1984 drum intro)
4. Dark Globe (Dave and Rick can't be the only Syd tributes; TML vocals)
5. The Fletcher Memorial Home
6. Perfect Sense (pt. 2)
7. Sea Shell And Stone/A Gentle Breeze Blew Through Life/Breathe
8. Lost Boys Calling
9. Hey You (Jon Carin does the screaming)
10. The Bravery Of Being Out Of Range
11. Each Small Candle (or Two Suns In The Sunset; depends on mood)
12. Amused To Death

ENCORES
1. The Tide Is Turning (get the crowd to sing along, Hey Jude-style)
2. Brain Damage
3. Eclipse

[shabana]

Fantasy Setlist:

Set One
1) Astronomy Dominee
2) Set The Controls
3) Welcome To The Machine
4) The Pros And Cons Of Hitchhiking (part X)
5) Sexual Revolution
6) Every Strangers Eyes
7) One Of These Days
Three Wishes
9) It's A Miracle
10) When The Tigers Broke Free (acoustic)
11) Granchester Meadows (acoustic)
12) Nobody Home (acoustic)
13) Another Brick In The Wall (medley parts I-III)

Set Two
1) Complete Animals

Encore
1) Wish You Were Here
2) Breathe (inc Breathe reprise)
3) Brain Damage
4) Eclipse

O I love your setlist! This would be my fantasy list too

[Sonic Destruction]

Why thank you

I thought maybe Rog could work the "Interstellar Overdrive" riff into "Set The Controls" as part of a spacerock opening segment. Also, he could consider performing the two "Amused To Death" tracks solo on guitar as part of the acoustic section.

[Yucateco]

ASOS and Interstellar Overdrive are highly improvisational

wasn?t ASOS one of the most structured songs Floyd ever made?

[Mr Tuck]

Here is what i think he will play on his 2007 tour:

Set One

1. In the Flesh
2. Mother
3. Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun
4. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I - V)
5. Have a Cigar
6. Wish You Were Here
7. Southampton Dock
8. The Fletcher Memorial Home
9. Perfect Sense, Parts 1 and 2
10. Leaving Beirut
11. Sheep


Set Two (The Dark Side of the Moon)

1. Speak to Me
2. Breathe
3. On the Run
4. Time
5. Breathe (Reprise)
6. The Great Gig in the Sky
7. Money
8. Us and Them
9. Any Colour You Like
10. Brain Damage
11. Eclipse

Thats pretty much exactly what he played when i saw roger at hyde park this year

heres mine:
1. In the Flesh
2. Shine on you crazy diamond (I-V)
3. The thin ice
4. Echoes
5. Fearless
6. Welcome to the machine
7. Leaving Beirut
8. Have a cigar
9. Fletcher memorial home
10. Astronomy domine

Part 2
DSOTM

[Mr Tuck]

ooh, stick hey you in there somewhere as well.
Some of the pros and cons of hitchiking would be good tooo

[PublicImage]

ASOS and Interstellar Overdrive are highly improvisational

wasn?t ASOS one of the most structured songs Floyd ever made?

Not at all. It has 4 sections, but each one was improvised except for Celestial Voices. That's the only part that really has any structure.

And it would most likely be crap with somebody other than Gilmour singing it.