live earth and roger

[corie]

i was thinking that bit was odd also ?

[jambo]

For the record Roger singing WYWH was horrible.

Sure his voice wasnt the best 30+ years ago but it sounds even worse now. He sounds like an old man (even with his studio produced help). David sang all those songs for a reason.

i think wywh sounds much better now... the "old" voice adds so much to that song

I'm gonna have to agree with Yuc on this one. The older, slightly more urgent and crokey vocals add another layer to the song, which I think makes it fantastic to listen to. I always choke up when I watch it on Live 8.