live remember a day ???

[lostplay]

from the 20 cd syd disc set
disc nine contains an amzing version of
remember a day
it sounds live ??
the vocals are clear !!! and i can hear some aud sounds ???
syd did play one or two guitar tracks on this song
i wonder if this is really live
or some great orb like re working of a floyd song ???

i searched the web for 3 days
no one comes even close to addressing this .

help

[zag]

Both HYGIY discs 9 and 10 are fan-created mixes.

[lostplay]

Both HYGIY discs 9 and 10 are fan-created mixes.

thanks for quick reply
it seemed to say that in some places
but i wasn't sure all songs were fan created

so are there any live versions of this song ???

[zag]

Nah, they never performed "Remember A Day" live, but what I know. I wasn´t there

[lostplay]

Nah, they never performed "Remember A Day" live, but what I know. I wasn´t there

yet after 2o 0dd yaers i found live main theme

[J Ed]

that Violence in Birmingham boot was a vinyl boot when I was a lad so the live Main Theme was known and circulating all that time
but it is possible Remember a Day was played live, theres only two 1967 shows circulating
we can only guess what they might have played other nights
and so many obscurities have emerged just in the last year anything is possible (eg Interstellar Zappadrive)

on the other hand: those two 1967 audience tapes display a band playing very loud feedback jams with inaudible vocals, which is supposedly how they usually sounded in those days
Remember a Day is probably too atmospheric a song to attempt in such an environment

[lostplay]

well i never knew about early boots at all until i searched every record shop in nyc . anyway what a treat !! alan/ main /syphlus //corrosion live
is violence in birm ?? the same show as amazing pudding ???

i fear that any bbc 67-8 songs may be lip sync
syd hated that more than any thing

the live bbc jug band blues seems like a lip sync deal
the video shows rog faking a sax a phone

some one said that in some early 68 floyd songs they were unsure of there vocals
so they mixed them very low
and getting back on topic the supposed fan created remember a day from disc nine is incredble

peace

[J Ed]

is violence in birm ?? the same show as amazing pudding ???

I belive we're talking about the same show

heres a description from a website called Fingals Cave

February 11 - The Town Hall, Birmingham, England
Recording Includes: Embryo, Main Theme (from 'More'), Careful with that Axe Eugene, Sysyphus, Violence Sequence, Set the Controls, Amazing Pudding (Atom Heart Mother)
Source: Audience
Comments:
CD Reference: The Amazing Pudding, Violence In Birmingham, Atomic Heart Mother, The Violent Pudding, Project Birmingham, Monopoly, Antiques And Curios, A Journey Through Time And Space, Electric Factory (wild card),
Fat Old Gigs, Umma & Gumma
LP Reference: Violence In Birmingham, The Live Biography:Volume 2-Interstellar Overdrive, In Memoriam
Quality: Fair

you might want to check that site as its a pretty good resource for what shows are circulating

there are lipsync'd TV promos for Remember A Day, I think theres a Belgian made one and a French one, both with Dave in place of Syd

[lostplay]

thanks a bunch J ED
THERE REALLY PLAYEED a lot of shows huh ..
=======
i found the two shows i saw /with r waters
roosvelt statium 1973
nassua colisium 1975
i had my years wrong